I Was a Planner Flunkie

by | Productivity Advice | 12 comments

My eyes lit up.

It was my very first day of work at my very first real job. The office coordinator had just said: “Send me an email by the end of the week with the SKU of the Franklin Covey planner you want.”

As a life-long lover of office supplies, with that phrase she put the proverbial cherry on top of this sweet treat.

I remember the day my black leather planner arrived and how I meticulously set up the pages just the way I wanted.

The post-purchase planner glow was short lived. Within 6 weeks I was back to using a steno pad and the calendar in LotusNotes.

I shouldn’t have been surprised. Every fall during middle school, high school, and college I would buy an academic planner with the same twinkle in my eye.

This would be the year I would no longer be a planner flunkie, I said (and believed) time after time.

After the Franklin Covey failure, I swore off planners for nearly a decade. I stuck to the basics, but I still longed to be a planner person.

Fast forward to the recent past, where I purchased a new planner amidst a blend of excitement and fear. Would this lead to inspired productivity or simply perpetuate my track record?

Much to my own surprise, it was the former – and I believe for a fascinating reason.


Attributes of a Planner You’ll Actually Use

It wasn’t until I stopped trying to force my square peg life into the uniform round hole of a fancy planner system that I finally found planner peace.

While a 3-ring system offers needed flexibility to use the planner when I want, it was actually adding in the element of choice to use it for what I want that made the difference.

In traditional planner systems – 3-ring and especially in bound – someone else makes the decision about what pages you need and how many of each. I believe this is why I was a planner flunkie for so long.

By starting first with my planning needs and then choosing specific inserts, I could create a customized planner I would actually use.

Plus, I wouldn’t have to give up using digital systems just to be a planner person. Instead I could choose how best to use both digital tools and a paper planner to organize my ideas and days.

Here’s a summary of lessons I’ve learned as a recovering planner flunkie:

There’s no such thing as one-size-fits-all when it comes to planners. Even the greatest design can’t make up for lack of functionality you need in a planner. For some, a bound planner may fit the bill. But if you’ve had trouble keeping up with a traditional, calendar-focused planner, then it might be time to consider alternatives.

Choose a durable binder you love; you can customize the insides. While you can sometimes buy 3-ring planner binders without any inserts, most often they come with a few dividers and some basic pages. Don’t be afraid to chuck those in favor of using inserts that you hand-select for their resonance with your style or needs.

Select a size that is realistic and matches your portability needs. Some people need to carry their planners away from home – and others just have no need to do so. Consider the size of bag you’ll need to house your planner when making selections. I thought A5 would be my holy grail, but personal is a better fit for the items I carry day to day.

Use specific inserts for the things you want to write down by hand. This goes back to the square peg in the round hole idea. Look for inserts designed for the way you live your life and how you like to plan your days, weeks, months, and years. You can even customize dividers to match the types of pages you have in your planner.

Take time to build good habits when using any new planning system. Being a planner flunkie in the past doesn’t mean you are destined to a planner-less life. If you customize your own system and then commit to using it, you’ll have an even greater chance of turning your streak around. Be patient with yourself as you adjust.


Bring in favorite digital tools as a companion where it makes sense. In a survey of our members here at Simple Scrapper, the majority of those who use paper planners also use some form of electronic tools for planning. Perhaps your favorite meal planner is an app; don’t put meals in your planner then and don’t feel guilty for how you choose to use any tool.

Be mindful of over-planning as well as mistaking planning for doing. Using a planner doesn’t mean you suddenly need to schedule your day into 30 minute increments or use washi tape to make it pretty – unless of course you want to. Look at this tool as simply a home for all the ideas in your head, creating additional space for more creativity and taking action.

The 2016 Simple Scrapper Planner is now available!

Did you find this post helpful?

We believe simple is not how your page looks, but how your scrapbooking hobby works. We have a free workshop called SPARKED and it is the best way to learn more about Simple Scrapper and start creating consistently.


  1. Sonja

    Oh that sounds so familiar! But I too am working at making my planner fit my need and am getting into a very good routine and system now. But it’s like you did. I ditched the orginal inserts. Downloaded some digital ones I loved but they also turned out to cause me to overplan and then having no energy left to take action. So I am continuing to tweek my system this year and I feel like I am getting there bit by bit. I am now using my A5 Filofax with a bullet journal approch and lots of tabs for all my projects. I have a wall calendar and Google CAlendar for family and general appointments and some monthly schedules printed out and hung up in my kitchen for big projects and building up my home based business. Making progress!

  2. Claudia

    Franklin Planner, Lotus Notes! Sounds too familiar. Thanks for bringing back the good ole Franklin Planner memories. But just like you I failed and never quite used them. Remember the Palm Pilots? Oh goodness. Even in this digital age I often find myself writing down all my to do lists on regular notebook paper, even though I have anErin Condren & InkWell Press planner in my dwars somewhere at home. Now I am eyeing Heidi Swapp’s personal planner for 2016, but I must not give in to temptation. Looking forward to see what you have up your sleeve πŸ™‚

  3. Cheryl

    I actually was a pretty successful user of a Franklin planner, probably because I also took the class. But don’t limit yourself to bound or ringed planners – consider a Traveler’s Notebook. My Every Day Carry is now a pocket sized TN with wallet, calendar, journal and bullet journal inserts. All of the other advice works well though – whether ringed or elastic bound.

  4. Judi

    Good insights about planners, Jennifer – thanks! I think this will help me in the future to not get so caught up in the latest craze and consider how I actually want to use my planner.

  5. Gab

    Great post Jennifer. I used to LOVE my Filofax until I got my first iPhone!

  6. Jenn

    Through trial and error (and being a Planner Flunkie, myself), I came to the same sort of realizations you did. My post about it is here: DIY Planners. πŸ™‚

    Glad I’m not alone! πŸ˜€

  7. Mary Kai

    I am a big fan of the ARC binders from Staples. Easy to customize.

    • Gretchen

      Yes! I found those last year and I love mine.

  8. Lisa

    I love this post, I am right there with you! I have tried so many that I don’t know what, if anything will work for me. Thanks for sharing and making me feel better πŸ™‚

  9. Tammy

    Great post! I finally did this myself this year. I want thrilled about using an ring binder at first, but I decided to do it this year so next year, perhaps, I’ll know what I want and them can bind it. However, I’m now loving the ease of adding pages however I want and I’m thinking that I’ll probably stay with this! Thanks again!

  10. Tammy

    This is all familiar to me also. It is so exciting to start up a planner but if you can’t keep up it does no good. I used cozi on my phone for a long time. I love reminders. I needed more so now I am using google. My husband works rotating days off so I can see when I can make plans, it syncs with everything. I have a great calendar at home that family things so everyone can see the basics and I have my three ring planner for things I want to organize.

  11. Nonarae

    I’m a planner flunkie as well πŸ˜‚ I never knew how to use them in school, and now I wish I had researched it further. Who would have guessed that one needed to set it up in advance and add due dates and such right away. I always struggles with not having the daily section. I always had the month at a glance and week at a glance sections, but could never find one (for a reasonable price) that had the daily things I wanted. I recently got an A5 binder and found some inserts I’m okay with, and 6 ring A5 printer paper to create my own inserts. I also never liked having it dated. I’d miss entire months of using the planner and then come back to find that I basically needed to buy a new one. Now I only use undated so if I don’t use my planner for a while, it’s no big deal at all. I’m really hoping it’ll fit my needs better this time.



  1. Simple Scrapper | August 2015 | sarathings - […] I’m not the planner type and this even looks good to me! And if you’ve tried and been a…
  2. How I Effectively Use My Planner for My Website - My Scrapbook Evolution - […] I Was a Planner Flunkie- An article from Simple Scrapper […]

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.


The Simple Scrapper community will encourage and support your unique creative journey.